Spec-Driven Development SDD — Humanoid Testing & System Validation

Share

(Human‑authored specification — governs testing, not test cases)

1. Purpose of This SDD

This SDD defines the governance, safety envelopes, autonomy boundaries, validation requirements, and evidence obligations for testing and system validation of a humanoid robot.

It ensures that all testing is:

  • safe
  • bounded
  • repeatable
  • auditable
  • aligned with physical irreversibility constraints
  • aligned with training and runtime governance

This SDD governs how testing must be conducted, not the individual test cases.

2. Scope

This SDD applies to:

  • locomotion testing
  • manipulation testing
  • perception testing
  • sensor fusion testing
  • human‑interaction testing
  • safety‑critical testing
  • regression testing
  • simulation‑to‑real validation
  • hardware‑in‑the‑loop testing
  • policy validation

It does not define:

  • manufacturing tests (covered by Hardware SDD)
  • training constraints (covered by Training SDD)
  • runtime autonomy rules (covered by Runtime SDD)

3. Test‑Time Safety Invariants

These conditions must always hold during testing:

  • Center of mass remains within stability polygon
  • Joint velocity ≤ rated limits
  • Joint torque ≤ rated limits
  • Force application remains within safe envelopes
  • Thermal load remains within safe margins
  • Collision detection remains active
  • Emergency stop overrides all commands
  • Sensor fusion (vision + IMU) remains valid
  • No single sensor failure may allow unsafe motion
  • No irreversible action may occur without explicit approval

If any invariant is violated, the robot must halt immediately.

4. Test‑Time Negative Requirements

The robot must never during testing:

  • operate with failed or uncalibrated sensors
  • disable collision detection
  • override safety interlocks
  • exceed human‑proximity limits
  • execute unvalidated trajectories
  • apply force without force‑feedback confirmation
  • exceed thermal or torque limits
  • perform irreversible actions (dropping, crushing, falling)
  • modify autonomy boundaries
  • modify safety zones
  • modify joint limits
  • flash firmware
  • generate new trajectories without validation

These are hard prohibitions.

5. Test‑Time Autonomy Boundaries

During testing, the robot may:

  • execute validated trajectories
  • perform manipulation tasks within force limits
  • navigate within mapped zones
  • collect telemetry
  • run diagnostics
  • operate in safe‑mode

The robot may not:

  • generate new trajectories
  • modify force limits
  • modify joint limits
  • modify safety envelopes
  • disable safety systems
  • operate outside the test environment
  • perform irreversible actions without preconditions

6. Test Preconditions

Testing may only begin if:

  • all sensors are calibrated
  • all diagnostics pass
  • test environment is validated
  • human safety perimeter is established
  • emergency stop is functional
  • test operator is present
  • robot is in IDLE state
  • no active error states exist
  • all required logs are enabled

7. Test Postconditions

Testing is only considered complete if:

  • no safety invariants were violated
  • no negative requirements were violated
  • no drift was detected
  • all evidence logs are complete
  • all error codes are resolved
  • robot returns to IDLE or SHUTDOWN state
  • test operator signs off

8. Test Environment Requirements

The test environment must:

  • include physical safety barriers
  • include human‑safe zones
  • include soft‑impact surfaces for fall testing
  • include calibrated markers for perception tests
  • include controlled lighting
  • include controlled floor friction
  • include controlled obstacles
  • include emergency stop access

The environment must not include:

  • untrained humans
  • uncontrolled objects
  • reflective surfaces that break perception
  • unbounded space

9. Test‑Time State Machine

Allowed states during testing:

  • IDLE
  • TASK_EXECUTION
  • ERROR_RECOVERY
  • SAFE_MODE
  • SHUTDOWN

Forbidden transitions:

  • ERROR_RECOVERY → TASK_EXECUTION
  • SAFE_MODE → TASK_EXECUTION
  • TASK_EXECUTION → BOOT

Testing must not proceed if the robot enters an undefined state.

10. Escalation Rules

If:

  • force deviation > 10% → halt
  • thermal rise > 5°C/min → cooling mode
  • human < 0.5 m → reduce speed to 10%
  • human < 0.25 m → halt
  • IMU drift > threshold → recalibration required
  • vision failure → safe‑mode
  • any invariant violation → halt

Escalation actions must be logged.

11. Evidence Requirements

Every test must produce:

  • joint trajectory logs
  • force‑torque logs
  • IMU traces
  • vision frames (hashed)
  • thermal profile
  • battery profile
  • error codes
  • safety interlock events
  • diagnostic results
  • environment configuration snapshot
  • operator signoff

Evidence must be:

  • immutable
  • timestamped
  • cryptographically hashed
  • linked to test ID
  • stored for audit

12. Physical Irreversibility Constraints

Testing must explicitly prevent:

  • falls
  • collisions
  • over‑torque
  • over‑force
  • over‑velocity
  • thermal runaway
  • dropping payloads
  • crushing objects
  • unsafe human contact

Testing must include:

  • reversible action constraints
  • safety envelope constraints
  • human‑proximity constraints
  • force‑feedback constraints
  • trajectory validation constraints

13. Simulation‑to‑Real Validation Requirements

Simulation must:

  • match physical robot dynamics
  • include domain randomization
  • include sensor noise
  • include perturbation events
  • enforce safety envelopes

Policies must be validated in:

  • simulation
  • hardware‑in‑the‑loop
  • controlled physical environment
  • supervised human environment

14. Regression Testing Requirements

Regression testing must include:

  • locomotion regression
  • manipulation regression
  • perception regression
  • sensor fusion regression
  • safety envelope regression
  • drift detection regression

Regression failures must block deployment.

15. Approval & Governance

Testing must be approved by:

  • robotics engineering
  • safety engineering
  • AI governance
  • test operator

Testing must not proceed without all approvals.

This is the complete Testing SDD — the governance contract for humanoid validation.

It defines:

  • what must be validated
  • what must never happen
  • what invariants must hold
  • what evidence must be produced
  • what boundaries constrain autonomy
  • what conditions must be met before and after testing
  • how physical irreversibility is prevented

This is the missing discipline that makes humanoid QA safe, governed, and auditable.

Read more